Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

Comment #6 --

A good tactic is to have a lessor character acknowledge the main character's emotions. It avoids making the main character too self aware, and it surprises both the reader and the main character.

My favorite example comes from Thom Jones's 'The Pugilist at Rest': A teenage boy awakes to his bullying stepfather. The son finally pummels the bully, then runs off to school. At the school he meets his girlfriend who looks at him aghast and asks, "Rory, why are you wearing pajama bottoms!? Why are you covered in blood?! Why are you CRYING??"

I've fudged the quote because I don't have the book at hand. But the trick is to have a detached character recognize the emotions that the main character is still blind -- traumatized -- to. It's a neat trick that takes the reader's breath away.

Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

Hello Chris --

Let's get started with Comment #1

The story is clear and linear, and at no time did I feel confused. You kept the actions going and kept the mood consistent: Just another day in chaos. The "Love" text on the end was a nice button.

That said, I wanted a hint at the character's emotions, and wonder if that might come via the recorded book. Whatever he's listening to, it can show us something secret about how he copes. For instance, if he's listening to Charles Dickens he might be sentimental and escapist. But if he's listening to a dystopian novel even MORE dystopian than his own world... that could land as funny.

It's comforting to witness suffering greater than your own. So if he's listening to Kafka or some other dire story, it puts his ordeal into perspective.

This is just two options. But instead of some banal police procedural, what other book would show us the narrator's emotional, inner life??? Who knows? The audio book might develop to become the larger overall book, while and narrator fades into the background.

Keep in mind, this is a clever trick: Reading a book within a book. The masterstroke of the TV show The Waltons was how that family was shown listening raptly to their radio, just as other families were watching raptly around their televisions watching the Walton family.

Portals within portals.

55 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?